Should Schools Ban Phones in Class?

Full script

Read the whole talk.

All slides in one place. Read it through once, then practice slide by slide.

1. 01Should Schools Ban Phones in Class?

   Good morning, everyone. I'm a high school teacher in Madrid, and every year our staff room has the same debate: should phones be banned in class? Today, I'll present both sides fairly before sharing my own view.

   大家早安。我是馬德里的一名高中老師，每年我們教師辦公室裡都會有同樣的爭論：上課時應該禁止使用手機嗎？今天，在分享我自己的看法之前，我會公平地介紹正反兩方的觀點。

2. 02A Global Trend

   This isn't just a local issue. According to UNESCO's 2023 Global Education Monitoring Report, about one in four countries had already banned smartphones in schools through a law or policy.

   這不只是一個地方性的問題。根據聯合國教科文組織的《2023年全球教育監測報告》，大約每四個國家中就有一個已經透過法律或政策禁止在學校使用智慧手機。

   Source: UNESCO, Global Education Monitoring Report 2023: Technology in education

3. 03The Case for a Ban

   Supporters of a ban say phones are a constant distraction. Even when a phone is silent, students keep thinking about it. A ban also gives students a break from social media during the school day.

   支援禁止的人說，手機會不斷讓人分心。即使手機靜音了，學生還是會一直想著它。禁止手機還能讓學生在上學期間暫時遠離社交媒體。

4. 04The Case Against a Ban

   On the other side, critics argue that phones can be powerful learning tools, for looking up words or recording experiments. They also say that school is the right place to learn how to use technology responsibly.

   另一方面，批評者認為，手機可以是強大的學習工具，可以用來查單詞或記錄實驗。他們還說，學校正是學習如何負責任地使用科技的地方。

5. 05What About Safety?

   Parents often raise another point: safety. They want to reach their children in an emergency. However, most bans simply keep phones in bags or lockers, so students still have them before and after class.

   家長們常常會提出另一點：安全。他們希望在緊急情況下能聯絡到孩子。不過，大多數禁令只是讓手機放在書包或儲物櫃裡，所以學生在上課前後仍然可以拿到手機。

6. 06Weighing Both Sides

   When we weigh both sides, the real disagreement is not about phones themselves. It's about whether schools should remove temptation, or teach students to manage it.

   權衡雙方觀點，真正的分歧其實不在於手機本身，而在於學校應該消除誘惑，還是教學生學會管理誘惑。

7. 07My View: Away by Default

   My own view is a middle path: phones away by default. They stay in bags, and they come out only when the teacher decides they're useful for a lesson. This keeps the focus, but still teaches responsible use.

   我自己的看法是走中間路線：預設把手機收起來。手機放在書包裡，只有當老師認為它對上課有用時才拿出來。這樣既能保持專注，又能教學生負責任地使用手機。

8. 08Conclusion

   To sum up, the question isn't simply phones or no phones. It's about when and how they are used. With clear rules, we can protect students' attention and still prepare them for a digital world. Thank you.

   總結一下，問題並不只是要不要手機，而是什麼時候用、怎麼用。有了明確的規則，我們既能保護學生的注意力，又能讓他們為數字世界做好準備。謝謝大家。