Good morning, everyone. Last year, I watched a rocket launch online, live, with millions of other people. It was exciting. But afterwards, my friend asked me a hard question: "Why spend so much money on space when we have so many problems on Earth?" Today, I'll try to answer that question fairly. First, I'll look at how much space really costs. Then, I'll give two arguments for space and the strongest argument against it. Finally, I'll give my conclusion.
Say this slide out loud, then listen to yourself.
Recordings stay on this device and disappear when you leave the page.
asked me a hard question
Asked something difficult to answer.
answer that question fairly
Reply in a balanced way, looking at both sides.
Finally, I'll give my conclusion
My last point will be my final opinion.
Highlighted words are on this slide. Tap a word to look it up on Google.
Full script
All slides in one place. Read it through once, then practice slide by slide.
Good morning, everyone. Last year, I watched a rocket launch online, live, with millions of other people. It was exciting. But afterwards, my friend asked me a hard question: "Why spend so much money on space when we have so many problems on Earth?" Today, I'll try to answer that question fairly. First, I'll look at how much space really costs. Then, I'll give two arguments for space and the strongest argument against it. Finally, I'll give my conclusion.
Let's start with the numbers. According to The Planetary Society, NASA's budget for 2024 was about 24.9 billion dollars. That sounds huge, and it is. But USAFacts, a non-profit that studies government data, reports that NASA's spending was only about 0.4% of all U.S. federal spending that year. In other words, for every 100 dollars the U.S. government spent, NASA got about 40 cents. Of course, other countries spend money on space, too, but the U.S. budget is the easiest to check, so I'll use it as an example. So space is expensive, but it's a small part of the total.
Sources: The Planetary Society, "NASA's FY 2024 Budget" ($24.875 billion); USAFacts, "National Aeronautics and Space Administration" (NASA spent $25 billion in FY 2024, 0.4% of the $6.78 trillion in federal spending)
Now, the case for space. My first reason is that space research often brings benefits back to Earth. Here's one example from NASA itself. In 1966, NASA paid an engineer to design a safer airplane seat that could absorb shock. The result was a new kind of foam, first sold in 1969 as "temper foam." Today, we call it memory foam, and it's in pillows and mattresses around the world. I sleep on a memory foam pillow every night, and I had no idea it was connected to space. This shows that money spent on space can create things we use every day.
Source: NASA Spinoff 2005, "Consumer, Home, and Recreation" (temper foam developed in 1966 under a NASA contract to improve airplane seat protection; commercialized in 1969)
My second reason is that space technology is already part of our daily lives. Think about GPS. According to GPS.gov, the official U.S. government website, the United States is committed to keeping at least 24 GPS satellites working, 95% of the time. Every time you use a map app, order a delivery, or call for help and share your location, you're using satellites in space. In other words, space isn't far away. It's in your pocket.
Source: GPS.gov, "Space Segment" (the United States is committed to maintaining the availability of at least 24 operational GPS satellites, 95% of the time; operated by the U.S. Space Force)
However, there's a strong argument on the other side. Big space programs often cost far more than planned. In 2021, NASA's own Office of Inspector General, which checks how NASA uses its money, projected that NASA would spend 93 billion dollars on its Artemis Moon program from 2012 to 2025. It also said that NASA's estimates significantly understate the real cost. Critics ask a fair question: what could that money do for health, schools, or climate change here on Earth? When I read this report, I understood my friend's question much better.
Source: NASA Office of Inspector General, "NASA's Management of the Artemis Missions" (IG-22-003, November 2021; projected $93 billion on Artemis from FY 2012 through FY 2025; estimates "significantly understate" the cost)
To be honest, I understand both sides, because of something that happened to me. Last year, I traveled abroad and got lost in a city late at night. My phone battery was low, and I didn't speak the language. But the map on my phone, using GPS, showed me exactly where I was and guided me back to my hotel. At that moment, I didn't think about budgets. I just felt thankful for those satellites. It made me realize that space technology is not only for astronauts.
So, is it worth it? In my view, yes, but with conditions. First, space programs should have honest budgets and clear goals from the start. Second, independent groups, like NASA's inspector general, should keep checking the costs, and governments should listen to them. And third, this is my own idea, but countries could share the costs by working together on big missions, so that no single country has to pay for everything. Without these conditions, I think my friend's criticism would be right.
To sum up, space is a small part of government spending, about 40 cents of every 100 dollars in the U.S. It has given us real benefits, like memory foam and GPS. But big programs can cost far more than planned, so the costs must be watched closely. That's why my answer is yes, space exploration is worth the money, if we spend it wisely. Thank you for listening. I'm happy to take your questions.
Sources: USAFacts, "National Aeronautics and Space Administration" (0.4% of federal spending in FY 2024); NASA Spinoff 2005; GPS.gov, "Space Segment"; NASA Office of Inspector General, IG-22-003 (2021)
Cover photo by SpaceX-Imagery on Pixabay