Right to Repair: Good Goal, but Let's Be Careful

Full script

Read the whole talk.

All slides in one place. Read it through once, then practice slide by slide.

1. 01Right to Repair: Let's Be Careful

   Good evening. I'm a product designer at an electronics company in Stockholm. Everyone likes the idea of repairing things instead of throwing them away, and so do I. But today, I'll argue that strong repair rules have risks we shouldn't ignore.

   晚上好。我是斯德哥尔摩一家电子公司的产品设计师。大家都喜欢把东西修好而不是扔掉这个想法，我也一样。但今天，我要论证严格的维修规定存在一些我们不应忽视的风险。

2. 02Where I Agree

   Let me be clear about where I agree. Reducing electronic waste is important. The EU's 2024 directive on repairing goods, which countries had to apply by July 2026, shows how seriously governments take it.

   首先，我想说清楚我赞同的地方。减少电子垃圾很重要。欧盟2024年关于商品维修的指令，要求各国在2026年7月之前实施，这说明各国政府对此有多么重视。

   Sources: Directive (EU) 2024/1799 on common rules promoting the repair of goods, EUR-Lex; European Commission, "Directive on repair of goods"

3. 03Concern 1: Design Trade-Offs

   My first concern is design. Customers want phones that are thin, light, and waterproof. Making every part easy to remove can mean thicker devices or weaker water protection. Every design is a trade-off.

   我的第一个担忧是设计。顾客想要又薄、又轻、还防水的手机。让每个零件都容易拆卸，可能意味着机身更厚，或者防水性能更弱。每一种设计都需要有所取舍。

4. 04Concern 2: Safety and Security

   Second, safety. Phone batteries can catch fire if they're handled badly. And when repairs happen anywhere, there's a risk of low-quality or fake parts, and even of someone accessing personal data.

   第二，是安全。手机电池如果处理不当，可能会起火。而且，如果维修在哪里都能进行，就有可能用到劣质零件或假冒零件，甚至可能有人趁机获取个人数据。

5. 05Concern 3: Costs Passed to Customers

   Third, cost. Keeping spare parts in stock for many years, for every model, is expensive. Companies will likely pass some of that cost on to customers, including people who never repair anything.

   第三，是成本。为每一款机型都储备多年的备用零件，成本很高。公司很可能会把其中一部分成本转嫁给顾客，包括那些从来不修任何东西的人。

6. 06A Balanced Approach

   So, what's the balanced approach? Focus on the most common repairs, like screens and batteries, and support certified independent repairers who are trained to work safely.

   那么，什么才是平衡的做法呢？把重点放在最常见的维修上，比如屏幕和电池，并且支持经过培训、能够安全作业的认证独立维修商。

7. 07Let's Watch the Results

   Now that the EU's rules apply, we'll get real data on prices, safety, and waste. I think other countries should watch those results carefully before copying the rules.

   现在欧盟的规定已经开始实施，我们将得到关于价格、安全和浪费的真实数据。我认为，其他国家在照搬这些规定之前，应该仔细观察这些结果。

   Source: Directive (EU) 2024/1799 on common rules promoting the repair of goods, EUR-Lex

8. 08Conclusion

   In conclusion, I support repair, but not at any cost. Good rules should balance waste, safety, and design. Let's get the details right. Thank you.

   总之，我支持维修，但不是不惜一切代价。好的规定应该在浪费、安全和设计之间取得平衡。让我们把细节做好。谢谢大家。